5 Players Who Could Lose Their Starting Jobs

Starting opportunities are among the most valuable assets in fantasy football, but they aren't always guaranteed throughout an NFL season. Whether because of inconsistent performances, emerging young talent, or changing offensive strategies, established starters can suddenly find themselves competing for playing time. As the 2026 season progresses, several players face circumstances that could threaten their roles and significantly impact their fantasy value.

1. kirk cousins, las vegas raiders

Kirk Cousins entered the 2026 season as Las Vegas's starting quarterback, but his position could become increasingly uncertain as the season progresses. The Raiders selected Fernando Mendoza with the first overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft, signaling their intention to build around the young quarterback. Although Cousins has provided veteran experience and productive passing performances, Mendoza represents the franchise's long-term future. If Las Vegas begins struggling or decides its rookie is ready, Cousins could eventually lose his starting position, making him a risky long-term fantasy option.

2. rhamondre stevenson, new england patriots

Rhamondre Stevenson faces significant competition for backfield opportunities from TreVeyon Henderson. Although Stevenson has established himself as a capable NFL running back, concerns about ball security and inconsistent performances have occasionally threatened his workload. Henderson's explosiveness and receiving ability give New England another attractive option, potentially allowing him to assume a larger role as the season progresses. While Stevenson remains involved in the offense, fantasy managers should monitor the distribution of carries and passing-down opportunities, particularly once Henderson is fully healthy.

3. tua tagovailoa, atlanta falcons

Tua Tagovailoa entered the 2026 season with an opportunity to revive his career in Atlanta, but his starting position is far from guaranteed over the long term. The Falcons also have Michael Penix Jr., a former first-round selection who remains an important part of the franchise's quarterback plans. Although Penix's recovery from a knee injury complicates the situation, his eventual availability could create another quarterback competition. If Tagovailoa struggles to produce consistently, Atlanta could decide to return to its younger option, potentially reducing his fantasy value.

4. deshaun watson, cleveland browns

Deshaun Watson entered the 2026 season facing considerable pressure to establish himself as Cleveland's long-term answer at quarterback. After several seasons disrupted by injuries and inconsistent performances, Watson faced competition from younger quarterbacks, including Shedeur Sanders. Cleveland's uncertainty at the position makes Watson particularly vulnerable if the offense struggles to generate consistent production. Although his experience gives him an opportunity to retain the starting role, another disappointing stretch could encourage the Browns to evaluate their younger alternatives.

5. jacory croskey-merrit, washington commanders

Jacory Croskey-Merritt emerged as an intriguing fantasy running back because of his opportunities in Washington's backfield, but his workload is not necessarily secure. Competition from Rachaad White creates uncertainty, particularly in passing situations where White's receiving experience provides an advantage. If Washington increasingly favors White on passing downs or expands his rushing involvement, Croskey-Merritt could see his opportunities decline. While he possesses the ability to produce valuable fantasy performances, managers should monitor his snap share and receiving involvement before assuming he will maintain a dependable starting workload.

conclusion

Ultimately, starting positions in the NFL are rarely guaranteed, especially when teams have younger players waiting for opportunities or established veterans struggling to perform. Cousins, Stevenson, Tagovailoa, Watson, and Croskey-Merritt all face different forms of competition that could threaten their fantasy value as the 2026 season progresses. Managers should pay close attention to coaching decisions, snap counts, and emerging replacements rather than relying solely on established depth charts. Recognizing potential changes before they occur can provide a significant advantage on the waiver wire and help prevent unexpected fantasy disappointments.